Yes. The San Francisco Sheriff's Office has acknowledged that jail staff recorded confidential attorney-client phone calls and shared some of those recordings with prosecutors, which California law generally forbids.
The admission is now in two official accounts. In a letter to the Public Defender's Office described by NBC Bay Area, Sheriff Paul Miyamoto called the breach a mistake, said the issue was discovered in September, and wrote that jail staff have since updated public defender phone numbers on the "no record" list and that he has suspended the further release of recorded phone calls. A sheriff's spokesperson described it to NBC as an administrative error that occurred inadvertently. NBC reported that Miyamoto's letter detailed five deputy public defenders whose calls were recorded.
An earlier account from Mission Local, published Nov. 12 and updated Nov. 13, reported that the Sheriff's Office said an "administrative breakdown" led the department to record more than a dozen confidential jail phone calls between people awaiting trial and their lawyers in the last two years, and then improperly share those recordings with prosecutors. The Public Defender's Office told Mission Local it had discovered at least 20 of its confidential phone calls with clients were recorded and delivered to prosecutors.
How the system is supposed to work matters here. The sheriff's department records nearly every phone call made from the jails, Mission Local reported, and often shares recordings with the district attorney's office. Attorney numbers are supposed to go on an exclusion list so privileged calls are not recorded. Spokesperson Tara Moriarty told Mission Local that some emails containing those excluded numbers were not processed correctly, and that a review found at least 38 phone numbers associated with the public defender's office were not properly registered. The public defender's office said every attorney whose calls were improperly shared had submitted their numbers.
Deputy Public Defender Kwixuan Maloof is one of the lawyers named in the later coverage. He told NBC he knows of five cases in which his conversations were recorded, learning of them by hearing his own voice on a recording, through an intern, and in one instance from opposing counsel at the District Attorney's Office who heard his voice and told him. Mission Local reported that Maloof had given his number to the sheriff's department on July 8, 2025, that at least five of his calls were recorded and shared in the last year, and that three of those calls were for homicide cases in which he discussed legal strategy. "I mean, [the prosecutor] cannot unhear what he heard," he told the paper. "You cannot un-ring that bell."
State law is strict on this point. NBC quoted Maloof saying it is "absolutely illegal" and "actually a felony to record a privileged conversation between a client and an attorney." Mission Local noted that in California it is a felony to intentionally record a conversation between someone in custody and their lawyer. The Sheriff's Office has described what happened as an administrative error, not as an intentional recording. Whether any criminal or professional consequences follow is a separate question that has not, in the reporting we have reviewed, been decided.
Moriarty told Mission Local the department froze its regular process of sharing recordings on Aug. 27, and that since then district attorney staff have had to subpoena recordings they want. NBC said the District Attorney's Office, in a prepared statement, said it is taking the situation seriously and remains committed to transparency but offered no further comment. Legal analyst Steven Clark told NBC that judicial oversight may be needed and that any deputy district attorney who reviewed the recorded calls should recuse themselves from those cases.
We will update this story if the sheriff, the public defender or the district attorney releases a complete count of affected cases, names any remedies for defendants, or announces a lasting change to how jail calls are recorded and shared.
