Supervisor Bilal Mahmood and Mayor Daniel Lurie on Thursday revived a plan to cut San Francisco's real-estate transfer tax on sales of $10 million or more, Mission Local reported. Under the revamped proposal, transfers of property worth $10 million to $25 million would be taxed at 3.5% instead of 5.5%, and transfers of $25 million or more at 4% instead of 6%. The cuts are smaller than the February version, which would have lowered those rates to 2.75% and 3%. Lurie called the package the BUILD Act and said it is meant to make it easier to build homes the city needs. Mahmood said he has the votes and expects the Board of Supervisors to pass it before the end of the year.
The stated target is stalled housing. Mission Local reported that the city has almost 88,000 housing units that are planned but not getting built, and that developers say they cannot secure loans to break ground. Corey Smith, executive director of the Housing Action Coalition, an industry advocacy group, said builders tell the coalition that "the current 6% transfer tax is the single biggest barrier to new housing that's within the city's control," because investors recoup money when a building is sold and want a large enough margin to take the risk. Constructing new housing in San Francisco currently costs $700,000 to $1.2 million per unit, Mission Local reported; the city estimates the tax cut would reduce costs by around $60,000 per unit. That is a city estimate, not a completed project ledger.
The new draft also adds exemptions that were not in the original plan. The first sale of a newly constructed building with three or more housing units would be exempt from the tax entirely. "Development agreement" projects — large complexes such as the plans for Treasure Island or Stonestown — would be exempt during early construction, when a master developer often sells parcels to other builders. Those extras matter, and so does what the cut still covers. Prop. I supporters argued earlier this year that a cut would also apply to commercial real estate and older apartment buildings, not only new housing. Dan Raile, a Democratic Socialists of America member and Prop. I volunteer leader, told Mission Local, "Rents are going through the roof, but building flippers really need a tax cut."
The revival follows the defeat of Prop. I, which would have locked in the higher rates and required a new ballot measure to lower them. It lost 52% to 48%. Lurie opposed it and, the publication said, featured prominently in a $2.8 million campaign against it, largely funded by real-estate interests. He and Mahmood argue this version is closer to revenue-neutral because voters also passed Prop. J, which requires properties going through foreclosure to pay the transfer tax. The controller expects Prop. J to bring in $100 million to $150 million a year, about the cost of the cut, but also found that Prop. J revenue would likely "decline significantly over time." "Our labor and housing partners told us revenue neutrality was essential, and we took that seriously," Mahmood said.
This is a proposed ordinance, not a tax change already in effect. The Board has not voted. Until it does, the current 5.5% and 6% rates still apply. Watch the Board calendar for the actual hearing, and read the controller's caveat about Prop. J revenue fading over time before treating the package as a wash for the general fund.
