Smoke from an urban fire does not look like smoke from a typical wildfire, at least not in the air chemistry that researchers measured during the Eaton Fire. A Nov. 12 write-up from the U.S. National Science Foundation, describing a paper published Oct. 28 in Science Advances, says the plume that rose over Altadena and the San Gabriel Valley in January 2025 carried a spike in certain toxic chemicals compared with most wildfire plumes.

The study, titled "Fire at the boundary: Airborne toxic metals from the 2025 Los Angeles urban firestorm," is the first detailed analysis of atmospheric particles in that smoke, according to a Caltech account of the work. Lead author Haroula Baliaka, a Caltech doctoral researcher, and colleagues used a continuously running air-monitoring station in Pico Rivera, about 11 miles south of Altadena and co-located with a South Coast Air Quality Management District site.

That station is one of 12 in the NSF-supported Atmospheric Science and Chemistry mEasurement NeTwork, or ASCENT, which NSF says uses state-of-the-art instruments to study aerosols. Nga Lee (Sally) Ng, Caltech's Elizabeth W. Gilloon Professor of Environmental Science and Engineering and Chemical Engineering, manages the network and is a corresponding author of the paper. All ASCENT data are available to the public, Caltech said.

In the fire's early stages, when many structures and vehicles were burning, the concentration of toxic metals in the atmosphere spiked dramatically compared with typical wildfires, NSF and Caltech both reported. The scientists found that, compared with most wildfire smoke, the urban plume was enriched more than 50-fold in lead, 7-fold in chlorine and bromine, and 3-fold in arsenic.

At the peak of the Eaton Fire's structural burning, they estimated that nearly 7 million people in the Los Angeles metropolitan area were exposed to 24-hour lead concentrations 80 times higher than typical urban values. The chemical signature then evolved as the blaze moved from urban areas into the mountains above Altadena and the Angeles National Forest.

The team compared those measurements with data from another ASCENT site at Rubidoux, California, which recorded the Airport Fire, a September 2024 blaze that burned 24,000 acres of vegetation in Riverside County. Potassium, which plants take up from soil and release when vegetation burns, was elevated in both plumes. Lead was not.

The Eaton Fire began on the evening of Jan. 7, 2025. Lead concentrations spiked across eastern Los Angeles and the San Gabriel Valley on Jan. 8 and 9, with the highest values measured directly downwind of Altadena, Caltech said. The ratio of potassium to lead was at its lowest then, around 5 to 1. As the fire moved into the mountains, the ratio increased toward wildfire-like values, about 50 to 1 by Jan. 11 and then into the hundreds by Jan. 12.

The researchers noted that typical lead concentrations in the Los Angeles basin have declined by more than two orders of magnitude, or about 99 percent, since the early 1980s, when leaded gasoline was being phased out. The January spike was dramatic against that modern baseline, they said, even if it was in line with what was once more typical. They also said scientists do not yet know the health effects of short-duration, high-concentration exposure of the kind millions of people in the region experienced, and they cautioned that the strong lead signature might be unique to the Eaton Fire because of the large number of older homes and structures that burned in Altadena.

NSF said the work improves models that help determine emergency response to future urban fires, including predictions of where toxic smoke will travel. Caltech professor Richard Flagan said the response to the Eaton Fire and to contamination of the debris left in its wake was predicated on the firestorm being a wildfire event, but "the Eaton Fire was an extreme urban fire event." The findings are distinct from criminal cases arising from other Los Angeles-area fires; they describe what was in the air, not who started a blaze.