The U.S. Department of Homeland Security said Friday that Immigration and Customs Enforcement does not need Alameda County's permission to enforce federal immigration law, the Pleasanton Weekly reported, a direct answer to a question hanging over Santa Rita Jail and the county's ICE-free zone policy.
"ICE enforces the law 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, in all 50 states, including in California. No sanctuary politicians are going to stop that," DHS said in an emailed statement quoted by the paper, a Bay City News account with additional local reporting. "ICE does NOT need to receive permission from local authorities to enforce federal immigration laws — a clear federal responsibility under Article I, Article II, and the Supremacy Clause."
The statement followed a cease-and-desist letter that interim County Counsel Andrea Weddle sent Monday, demanding that agents stay away from Santa Rita Jail. The letter said ICE has used the jail's parking lot, lobby and surrounding areas to make arrests, which a county ordinance prohibits and which "creates significant safety risks" for sheriff's personnel and the public. It cited a Nov. 1 incident in which an agent allegedly chased someone from the parking lot into the public lobby and "forcibly detained him," and a Nov. 8 "physical confrontation" in the same lobby, and said agents continued to use county property after being told not to by Sheriff's Office command staff.
DHS acknowledged the Nov. 1 arrest and said agents detained Norlan Jose Alvarez Gonzalez, 26, of Nicaragua, in a targeted action after he was released from the jail following an alleged DUI arrest, the Pleasanton Weekly reported. According to DHS, he entered the country illegally in January 2024, was arrested by Customs and Border Protection, later released, and was issued a final order of removal on July 16 after allegedly failing to appear for immigration hearings.
Supervisor Nikki Fortunato Bas said the county is determined to stand up to unauthorized ICE activity and that aggressive tactics are scaring people away from medical care, county services and jail visits. "ICE continues to ignore our County ICE Free Zones policy, so I will continue to stand with our community and advocate for additional county enforcement action," she said in a statement.
KTVU on Friday broadcast jail surveillance video of the Nov. 8 lobby clash and interviewed Sheriff Yesenia Sanchez, who said, "I can't have that happening in my jail. I can't have pushing and shoving." She said she locked down the lobby and restricted access after more than one incident, and that the jail is not a place for ICE enforcement or for public protest. Sanchez said she had noticed agents in the lobby and parking lot for three to four weeks and had called as high as the attorney general about her options. KTVU said the county letter went to Julio Hernandez, ICE's acting field director in San Francisco, and allowed agents on the property only for official business such as a signed judicial warrant.
The Pleasanton Weekly said the dispute comes amid a regional surge that has included high-profile arrests of a University of San Francisco nursing professor and a UC Berkeley student, at least five arrests in San Mateo County and 19 in Alameda County in recent weeks, four arrests in Livermore on Nov. 5, and reports of ICE vehicles at a Pleasanton hotel. Monterey County also sent its own cease-and-desist letter after agents allegedly blocked access to county facilities; one Oct. 27 incident put that county's jail on lockdown for three hours, the paper reported.
For people visiting Santa Rita, the practical takeaway is unsettled: the county says the lobby and lot are off limits to ICE, and the federal government says it does not need permission to be there.
