By 21-20, according to Bucknell's official recap and official box score. The official box listed a 21-20 Colgate win over Bucknell on Saturday at Christy Mathewson-Memorial Stadium in Lewisburg, Pa. Official records were Colgate 7-5 and 6-3 in the Patriot League, and Bucknell 1-11 and 0-9. Kickoff was listed at 1:02 p.m., the game ended at 3:59 p.m., and the official duration was 2 hours, 57 minutes. Attendance was 637. The official weather line was sunny.
The official scoring summary said Juan Garanton's 38-yard field goal at 10:58 of the first quarter, after a four-play, 3-yard drive, made it 3-0 Bucknell. The official recap said Deuce Geter forced a fumble and Nick Hoying recovered it at the Colgate 25. Jackson Kilburg then found Peyton Way for an 84-yard touchdown, with Luke Vogeler's kick, at 5:06, making it 7-3 after a three-play, 96-yard drive. Emmett Dowling's 21-yard pass to Sam Milligan, with Garanton's kick, made it 10-7 with 1:13 left in the first quarter. Milligan's 1-yard run, with Garanton's kick, made it 17-7 at 8:23 of the second quarter, and Garanton's 35-yard field goal at 2:16 made it 20-7 at halftime.
The official recap has a line saying the Bison "took a 10-0 lead." The official scoring summary never shows a 10-0 score, and this account uses the official table: Bucknell led 10-7 after the first quarter and 20-7 at halftime. In the third quarter, Joey Tomasso's 8-yard pass to P.J. Holmes, with Vogeler's kick, made it 20-14 with nine seconds left, the official summary said, after a 10-play, 66-yard drive. Tomasso's 12-yard run, with Vogeler's kick, made it 21-20 with 3:14 left in the fourth quarter after a 12-play, 68-yard drive.
The official recap said Zach Jones intercepted Dowling after Trooper Price tipped a pass, Ayden Murray forced a fumble that Calogero LoGrasso recovered near the Bucknell 9-yard line with just under a minute left, and Blake Turner intercepted a deep ball to end it. Official team statistics listed Bucknell with 344 total yards, 253 passing, and 91 rushing, and Colgate with 301, 192, and 109. Time of possession was 32:26 to 27:34. Official leaders included Dowling, 25 of 35 for 253 yards, one touchdown, and two interceptions; Milligan, 12 catches for 174 yards; Michael Cadden, 42 rushing yards; and Way, 133 receiving yards. The official recap said Milligan finished the season with 77 receptions, passing Eric Weatherly's 75 in 2024.
